Stephen Toulmin was a contemporary philosopher who broke down the anatomy of an argument. His book, The Uses of Argument, identifies 6 key elements of an argument -- The primary elements include the Claim, Grounds, and Warrant; the secondary elements include the Backing, Qualifier, and Rebuttal. https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/academic_writing/historical_perspectives_on_argumentation/images/20190305Toulmin4.jpg Toulmin's concept that through analyzing these elements of an argument, you could analyze the overall logic of any argument. The CLAIM , also known as the assertion of proposition, is what you want your audience to believe. The GROUNDS , or evidence, is why your audience should believe your claim. Importantly, this is not an opinion. The WARRANT , or inferential leaf, is how the audience is able to connect the grounds to the claim. These make up the primary elements of an argument and determine if an argument holds any weight whatsoever. The fol...
Reddit is a breeding ground for poorly formulated arguments and pointless "trolling". People get a kick out of having an argument that will clearly never end in consensus but rather just to argue for arguments sake. https://www.redditinc.com/assets/images/blog/reddit_header_2023-11-28-222257_hthh.png I chose to look a NBA Reddit, a notoriously controversial space with no real rules or etiquette. This argument asks the question, " If a team of the 5 best college players at every position went against a team of the 5 worst NBA players who would win?". This topic is inherently sent up for failure as it's a hypothetical with no firm variables and no right answers. One of the first comments concludes with the statement, "People in this thread are insanely stupid.", this is a problematic way to finish what might have been a coherent argument as they finish with an unnecessary inflammatory comment. Later in the thread someone comments, "dumb post lol re...